Chelsea 2-0 Dortmund (Aggregate 2-1)

[Fulham Broadway 16,862]

15 minutes ago, OhForAGreavsie said:

I must be misunderstanding you here because I don't see why a keeper shouldn't be allowed to play the ball outside the penalty area. He has the same 'rights' as any other player. It's just that he has special rights when he in his own penalty area. When he's doing a drop kick from the edge of his penalty area, as long as he doesn't handle the ball outside the area, why can't he can drop it wherever he likes? 

Sorry OFAG yes, what I've seen is so many keepers taking the drop kick when handling the ball outside the area -seems to be a blind spot to officials, though it's more noticeable when watching on TV

[bigbluewillie 1,859]

29 minutes ago, OhForAGreavsie said:

I must be misunderstanding you here because I don't see why a keeper shouldn't be allowed to play the ball outside the penalty area. He has the same 'rights' as any other player. It's just that he has special rights when he in his own penalty area. When he's doing a drop kick from the edge of his penalty area, as long as he doesn't handle the ball outside the area, why can't he can drop it wherever he likes? 

Yes! but not when he's still holding the ball, as Fulham Broadway say's

I've seen so many keepers holding onto the ball on their run up to launching the kick and then encroaching they are hold the ball outside the penalty area so long as there is at least 1mm of the keepers back foot on a part of the white line...to me it's handball.

But you're going to tell me the law has changed and they're allowed to do it, this and every aspect that they have changed is ruining the game, not making it better.

I think i'd better desist on this subject, before I get pulled to order, may we can have a thread regarding the laws of the game.

 

Edited March 10, 2023 by bigbluewillie

[OhForAGreavsie 5,892]

5 hours ago, Fulham Broadway said:

Sorry OFAG yes, what I've seen is so many keepers taking the drop kick when handling the ball outside the area -seems to be a blind spot to officials, though it's more noticeable when watching on TV

 

5 hours ago, bigbluewillie said:

Yes! but not when he's still holding the ball, as Fulham Broadway say's

I've seen so many keepers holding onto the ball on their run up to launching the kick and then encroaching they are hold the ball outside the penalty area so long as there is at least 1mm of the keepers back foot on a part of the white line...to me it's handball.

But you're going to tell me the law has changed and they're allowed to do it, this and every aspect that they have changed is ruining the game, not making it better.

I think i'd better desist on this subject, before I get pulled to order, may we can have a thread regarding the laws of the game.

 

Ah, I get you. I can't say I've noticed that. Maybe officials have taken their eyes off this because keepers don't kick from hands anywhere near as often as they used to.

These days it should actually be easier for the linos to monitor this. In the old days they would jockey level with the front edge of the penalty area watching to see that keepers didn't carry the ball out of the area, then sprint hell for leather after the kick to get in line with the last defender who had pushed up towards halfway. Nowadays, the last defender is usually standing next to the goalkeeper. 🙂

[Magic Lamps 11,655]

5 hours ago, bigbluewillie said:

Yes! but not when he's still holding the ball, as Fulham Broadway say's

I've seen so many keepers holding onto the ball on their run up to launching the kick and then encroaching they are hold the ball outside the penalty area so long as there is at least 1mm of the keepers back foot on a part of the white line...to me it's handball.

But you're going to tell me the law has changed and they're allowed to do it, this and every aspect that they have changed is ruining the game, not making it better.

I think i'd better desist on this subject, before I get pulled to order, may we can have a thread regarding the laws of the game.

 

It’s crazy keepers get away with handling outside the area almost every time. Even the blatantly obvious ones like Martinez in the 2020 FA cup final

It is never even checked. they could easily use the offside line technology for that esp when it’s preventing a goal. 
pretty sure the bvb goalie did Cary the ball outside the he box when he snatched it before Sterling but no one bat an eye. 

[Vesper 28,855]

On 09/03/2023 at 18:11, Strike said:

 

 

you do not seem to understand the basic rules of the game (ie. the penalty arc)

you can plainly see (Özcan is on the right) he is within 10 yards of the pen spot (as in the Dortmund player directly behind Kai) 

Özcan is INSIDE THE PEN ARC

VAR showed the replay from multiple angles during the game, and you could see he was within 10 yards

 

both were inside the arc BEFORE Kai even touched the ball

 

 

https://www.thefa.com/football-rules-governance/lawsandrules/laws/football-11-11/law-14---the-penalty-kick

 

CASE CLOSED