The Benitez Thread

[xPetrCechx 13,565]

  On 19/01/2013 at 20:08, Tomo-91 said:

AVB and Robbie aside, all those managers had superior squad's. Jose and Claudio had shitloads to spend on whoever they wanted, Avram, Phil, Hiddink and Carlo inherited the squad in the peak cycle. Rafa had neither of those luxury's.

Jose, as far as i am aware, had the worst end out of all the managers.

Brendan Rodgers oversaw Liverpool's worst league start for over 100 years, does that make him the worst Pool manager in that period?

Can You rate our managers from the past 10 years?

[Tomo 21,741]

  On 19/01/2013 at 20:10, xPetrCechx said:

Can You rate our managers from the past 10 years?

In terms of what they contributed

1. Mourinho

2. Ancelotti

3. Di Matteo

4. Hiddink

5. Clarke

6. Ranieri

7. AVB

8. Scolari

Ill judge Rafa on the scale when he leaves.

[xPetrCechx 13,565]

  On 19/01/2013 at 21:27, Tomo-91 said:

In terms of what they contributed

1. Mourinho

2. Ancelotti

3. Di Matteo

4. Hiddink

5. Clarke

6. Ranieri

7. AVB

8. Scolari

Ill judge Rafa on the scale when he leaves.

[zolayes 14,489]

  On 19/01/2013 at 21:27, Tomo-91 said:

In terms of what they contributed

1. Mourinho

2. Ancelotti

3. Di Matteo

4. Hiddink

5. Clarke

6. Ranieri

7. AVB

8. Scolari

Ill judge Rafa on the scale when he leaves.

you undervalue Ranieri's contribution considerably

[xPetrCechx 13,565]

  On 19/01/2013 at 21:44, zolayes said:

you undervalue Ranieri's Grant's contribution considerably

[Rmpr 8,977]

  On 19/01/2013 at 21:27, Tomo-91 said:

In terms of what they contributed

1. Mourinho

2. Ancelotti

3. Di Matteo

4. Hiddink

5. Clarke

6. Ranieri

7. AVB

8. Scolari

Ill judge Rafa on the scale when he leaves.

1. Mourinho

2. Ancelotti

3. Di Matteo

4. Ranieri

5. Hiddink

6. Clarke

7. AVB

8. Scolari

Fixed

[xPetrCechx 13,565]

  On 19/01/2013 at 22:00, Rmpr said:

1. Mourinho

2. Ancelotti

3. Di Matteo

4. Ranieri

5. Hiddink

6. Clarke

7. AVB

8. Scolari

Fixed

1. Mourinho

2. Ancelotti

3. Di Matteo

4. Ranieri

5. Hiddink

6. GRANT!!!

7. AVB

8. Scolari

Fixed

[Hutcho 8,443]

Clarke wasn't a manager of ours... Only an assistant.

For me it is:

Jose

Rdm (Holy grail)

Ancelotti

Hiddink

Ranieri

Grant

Avb

Benitez

Scolari

[Tomo 21,741]

@, It was my way of implying who i thought was actually in charge in 07/08.

@zolayes your right ill probably put Ranieri up a bit thinking again.

[Rmpr 8,977]

@ dont worry, I got what you meant (hence I kept Clarke).

[Bacika 188]

  On 16/01/2013 at 22:23, FriendlyMailman said:

Maybe abramovixh hasn't offered enough money to pep?

Or Guardiola is just afraid to come to EPL, and choose less competitive league, where Bayern is way better than the rest of the league. Dortmund did mix things up in the last 2 years, but I think it is their maximum...it's again Bayern's era, where other teams don't stand a chance. So guardiola was playing on safe card Even I could win title in Germany with Bayern

[Hutcho 8,443]

  On 19/01/2013 at 22:23, Tomo-91 said:

@, It was my way of implying who i thought was actually in charge in 07/08.

@zolayes your right ill probably put Ranieri up a bit thinking again.

Ok fair enough... Was getting weird as I assumed everyone must know that lol.

[Hutcho 8,443]

  On 19/01/2013 at 22:33, Rmpr said:

@ dont worry, I got what you meant (hence I kept Clarke).

Don't lie about it... B-)

[Rmpr 8,977]

  On 19/01/2013 at 22:48, Hutcho_CFC said:

Don't lie about it...

Just because you cant read between the lines does it mean I cant either?

[Hutcho 8,443]

  On 19/01/2013 at 22:49, Rmpr said:

Just because you cant read between the lines does it mean I cant either?

Errrrmmmmmm.... Yes :-D

[TorontoChelsea 4,064]

  On 19/01/2013 at 21:44, zolayes said:

you undervalue Ranieri's contribution considerably

Everyone always does. He brought Lampard, Cech, Robben, Makalele, and Gallas to Chelsea. He played Terry and made him Captain. He contributed much more to the club than Hiddink who was simply a good manager for a handful of games. Mourinho's team was actually mostly Ranieri's (and even Vialli's) team. In fact, I'd have him second behind Mourinho. (I guess some of it depends on what you mean "contributed". Lasting legacy? How well we did under them?

I'd have it:

1) Mourinho- we became a dominant team when he was manager and helped forge our identity. He also bought players like Drogba and Carvalho who were key for us well after he left.

2) Ranieri,-Reasons above

3) Ancelotti-Had our best year under him. Transfer legacy is poisonous though.

Other than that, I don't think our recent managers "contributed" all that much. Largely because no other managers has managed even a season worth of games.Grant has the best success, managed the longest, and had very good transfers but still not much of a legacy really, If you're going back even a little further both Gullit and Vialli contributed a lot. We had or first success under them. We started playing some beautiful football. We were an exciting team. We even within 5 points of winning the Premier League one year. We had a ton of top transfers in this era as well. (Zola, RDM, Leboeuf , Desailly, Poyet, Cudicini, Hasselbaink, Gudjohnson, Flo, Chris Sutton (how did that get in there?) etc.... In fact, our 96/97 and 97/98 transfers were probably our best if you consider value. We bought Babayaro, Le Saux, De Goey, and Poyet, Zola, Lebeouf, and Vialli. The whole thing cost us well under 30M pounds.

[Kojo 4,676]

I don't even think i could imagine a long term manager, it's just weird thinking about it.

[22mek22 133]

Lots of speculation about Moyes....what you think?