The English Football Thread

[The only place to be 11,313]

Shows you, even the best of defenders can make grave errors. Kompany has just came back from injury though so this stuff happens.

That's why I wish people would just let Luiz get his match fitness up first before chastising him all the time.

It was a fucking slice, a freak mistake. Will he be dropped for it like Luiz has been twice already this season for shit performances??

But Luiz will be great....just give him a chance

[The Skipper 20,593]

It was a fucking slice, a freak mistake. Will he be dropped for it like Luiz has been twice already this season.

But Luiz will be great....just give him a chance

Was it an error or not though? There was barely any pressure on him and he mishit it.

My point is that he's not fully match fit so stuff like that happens. It's the same with Luiz.

[bushman 2,043]

Negredo just played a world class through ball, 4-2 City game over

Fucking entertaining game, something can't be say about us atm

Wait till Monday. Plenty of entertainment, then. Ferda´s show, tripping over the ball, his specialty.

[The only place to be 11,313]

Was it an error or not though? There was barely any pressure on him and he mishit it.

My point is that he's not fully match fit so stuff like that happens. It's the same with Luiz.

Running towards goal and tried to wrap his (slightly) weaker foot round it. Shit like that happens, like Courtois misjudging the flight of the ball against Zenit.

It's got nothing to do with fitness or anything. It's football. Luiz's problems are the result of a lack of focus.

If he had one ounce of Kompany's commitment then Luiz would be the best defender in the world.

[Mouri_Matic 560]

Wait till Monday. Plenty of entertainment, then. Ferda´s show, tripping over the ball, his specialty.

Will he even touch the ball or have enough times on it to do that

[Sidzeret 2,257]

It was a fucking slice, a freak mistake. Will he be dropped for it like Luiz has been twice already this season for shit performances??

But Luiz will be great....just give him a chance

Atleast that didn't cost them the match- no point deficit because of that.

Same cannot be said about our freak mistakes.

[The Skipper 20,593]

Running towards goal and tried to wrap his (slightly) weaker foot round it. Shit like that happens, like Courtois misjudging the flight of the ball against Zenit.

It's got nothing to do with fitness or anything. It's football. Luiz's problems are the result of a lack of focus.

If he had one ounce of Kompany's commitment then Luiz would be the best defender in the world.

Highly doubt that if Luiz did the same thing you'd say that "it's just football".

Regardless. Luiz does have the commitment though, just watch him play for Brazil or even for us in the second half of last season; I do get your point. I think that Jose isn't getting the best out of him at the moment but injuries have played a part too.

IMO he needs a good spell in the side to get back to the level he was at last season.

[The Skipper 20,593]

Atleast that didn't cost them the match- no point deficit because of that.

Same cannot be said about our freak mistakes.

Because they have better strikers and their offensive system is a lot better than ours so their attack can bail them out if their defenders make mistakes.

[Barbara 15,149]

Highly doubt that if Luiz did the same thing you'd say that "it's just football".

Regardless. Luiz does have the commitment though, just watch him play for Brazil or even for us in the second half of last season; I do get your point. I think that Jose isn't getting the best out of him at the moment but injuries have played a part too.

IMO he needs a good spell in the side to get back to the level he was at last season.

I agree double standards are everywhere (not only here, not only about Luiz, not only about football).

I swear I never read any of Luiz's critics here saying one of his mistakes it's just football. He had a hell of a season, and they say it wasn't that great. It's perception and it can't be changed, which is why I don't bother anymore. If I read someone blaming him for Sunderland's first goal (which wasn't a mistake btw, but he wasn't fortunate either), then I suppose calling Kompany mess something that's part of football is okay.

When was the last time Luiz did cost us a match though? I mean when one of his mistakes led to a goal and that goal took away our win? This is a serious question.

[Sidzeret 2,257]

Because they have better strikers and their offensive system is a lot better than ours so their attack can bail them out if their defenders make mistakes.

Exactly my point.

Yet all the blame seems to be attached to our defence.

[The only place to be 11,313]

Regardless. Luiz does have the commitment though, just watch him play for Brazil

Exactly. Maybe we should put some yellow on the kit and then he might play like he does for Brazil.

We could put some green on so Mikel plays like he does for Nigeria. Or we just sell them both and buy Zouma and Witsel.

[The only place to be 11,313]

When was the last time Luiz did cost us a match though? I mean when one of his mistakes led to a goal and that goal took away our win? This is a serious question.

When was the last time he was dropped? A few weeks ago and not long before that as well.

Great player in theory but a liability on it and the supporters' patience is wearing thin. Watch the goal mouth scramble against Palace and watch Luiz. It's utterly incredible. I'm not kidding.

[The Skipper 20,593]

Exactly. Maybe we should put some yellow on the kit and then he might play like he does for Brazil.

We could put some green on so Mikel plays like he does for Nigeria. Or we just sell them both and buy Zouma and Witsel.

Yeah conveniently ignore that I also said for us last season...

[bushman 2,043]

Will he even touch the ball or have enough times on it to do that

I can´t wait. The Jose show must go on.

As I look at the PL standings, I see Chelsea on 4th. If Everton wins tomorrow, Arsenal beats Chelsea on Monday, the team is 5th.

[Barbara 15,149]

When was the last time he was dropped? A few weeks ago and not long before that as well.

Great player in theory but a liability on it and the supporters' patience is wearing thin. Watch the goal mouth scramble against Palace and watch Luiz. It's utterly incredible. I'm not kidding.

I can accept that. The same way imo Zouma our Cahill aren't any better or any closer and cost matches as much (or goals, or whatever). Cahill has made more mistakes than Luiz this season imo. The thing is his mistakes are way more subtle, many times Cech saved his ass with good defenses or the strikers from opposition screwed the chances he gave them; still all blame is on Luiz. That's my point.

Luiz is Mourinho's second CB in the team, the thing is he was in shocking form a couple of months ago. Then he was injured and now he's not in form. Wait a couple of weeks until he's in form and come talk to me again about our defense. He'll continue to make mistakes (all CBs do), but in form (physically and with match rhythm) Luiz even when he isn't at the top of his game is much better than the current Cahill we have. Cahill had a very solid start of season, but he's been collecting mistakes for a while now. His specialty seems to be man-watch, be out of position and move at snail speed (which is reason enough for him to position himself better, but still he doesn't) but many here disregard those as a mistake. If he doesn't break someone's leg inside the box, make a pass to an opponent and miss a tackle then he's exempt from any responsibilities. Good thing for him he doesn't do any of those (he does miss the eventual tackle here and there, as any CB in the world)

Yeah conveniently ignore that I also said for us last season...

which was my point even before his post. He had a great season for us, many dismiss it as good and some even not good enough showcasing a couple of mistakes in a 60-match season.

[The only place to be 11,313]

Yeah conveniently ignore that I also said for us last season...

He was better for us last season, but still not the defender we thought he'd be when we signed him and plenty of people were convinced he was a central midfielder. Hoddle still does in fact and I'm inclined to agree.

[Ainsley Harriott 2,732]

[The only place to be 11,313]

I can accept that. The same way imo Zouma our Cahill aren't any better or any closer and cost matches as much (or goals, or whatever). Cahill has made more mistakes than Luiz this season imo. The thing is his mistakes are way more subtle, many times Cech saved his ass with good defenses or the strikers from opposition screwed the chances he gave them; still all blame is on Luiz. That's my point.

Luiz is Mourinho's second CB in the team, the thing is he was in shocking form a couple of months ago. Then he was injured and now he's not in form. Wait a couple of weeks until he's in form and come talk to me again about our defense. He'll continue to make mistakes (all CBs do), but in form (physically and with match rhythm) Luiz even when he isn't at the top of his game is much better than the current Cahill we have. Cahill had a very solid start of season, but he's been collecting mistakes for a while now. His specialty seems to be man-watch, be out of position and move at snail speed (which is reason enough for him to position himself better, but still he doesn't) but many here disregard those as a mistake. If he doesn't break someone's leg inside the box, make a pass to an opponent and miss a tackle then he's exempt from any responsibilities. Good thing for him he doesn't do any of those.

which was my point even before his post. He had a great season for us, many dismiss it as good and some even not good enough showcasing a couple of mistakes in a 60-match season.

I couldn't give a fuck if Cahill is worse. He isn't wanted by Barca and we didn't spend £24 million on him.

I can forgive Cahill because his flaw is that he's just not very good. David Luiz has more talent than almost any central defender in the world but it doesn't count for shit if he doesn't try and get the most out of it. I'm so fed up with his lack of commitment, his stupid brainfarts and the continuing adoration because of his sideshow bob hair and Miley Cyrus mannerisms.

Gary Neville nailed-him correctly. On his day he's amongst the best in the world but he can't be relied on. That's why he's been dropped twice this season and why any serious bid should be considered.