I share the same thought brother.
Last season I was one of the fews that wanted Gallagher here, while many wanted him gone.
Now the same that had the same opinion now want him to stay.....
Well I don't follow that and I see the same thing as you. Gallagher was good for last season as we needed to continue with what we had. And after one full season giving good chances to him I realize the same as you. He is not a game changer and similar like Mount he is very limited. I see Gallagher kind of of like Milner, those players are good to have BUT and and that's a big BUT if you get a good price for him then it's a no brainer, is best to sell him.
And is you mentioned in a more Pep style of futbol I don't see a space for Gallagher. So sell for the right price.