Gary Cahill

[The Skipper 20,609]

You don't have to be a world class player to be an amazing captain.. look at Roy Keane.

Keane wasn't world class perhaps, but he was still a very, very, very good player, and also his leadership qualities were always far better than Cahill's were.

[Beigl 1,387]

Why didn't get the World-class tackle to deny Campbell a free-shot on goal from 14 metres any recognition here?

Thought it was excellent.

[lucio 5,418]

Why didn't get the World-class tackle to deny Campbell a free-shot on goal from 14 metres any recognition here?

Thought it was excellent.

because he was horrendous apart from that. and by now, we know cahill we make last ditch heroic tackles , it was no surprise

[Myself 793]

Keane wasn't world class perhaps, but he was still a very, very, very good player, and also his leadership qualities were always far better than Cahill's were.

I'm not comparing their leadership qualities at all, in that respect Keane shits all over Cahill. just think Keane was a ood player witu exceptional leadership qualities, not a world class player

[MrExcalibur100 7,124]

You could argue perhaps he could have been tighter on Fellaini for the first ball in the build up to their goal.

[CHOULO19 24,332]

You could argue perhaps he could have been tighter on Fellaini for the first ball in the build up to their goal.

Understatement of the month, that!

I'm gonna go with he didn't know/forgot that he was supposed to be marking Fellaini after Iva went off. Free header from 8 yards out. What a stop by Thibaut!

[Nike 373]

Last year people said Cahill was the best CB in the EPL.

I said it was the system.

I wonder what people think now of cahill.

[iseah100 5,612]

Last year people said Cahill was the best CB in the EPL.

I said it was the system.

I wonder what people think now of cahill.

Still damn good.

[lucio 5,418]

Last year people said Cahill was the best CB in the EPL.

I said it was the system.

I wonder what people think now of cahill.

exposed and weak (in some areas)

[Stats 7,136]

Last year people said Cahill was the best CB in the EPL.

I said it was the system.

I wonder what people think now of cahill.

I still think he is up there. Thought he was quality once again today. It is something that most fans seem to do in terms of being harsh on our players. Other fans and pundits see different. For instance earlier in the match, the commentator said something down the lines of "Cahill has really turned into an excellent all round CB". But basically giving him huge compliments.

Despite his flaws he is one of my favourite players. Think he is a quality CB. Reminds me of Koscielny. Both rash, like to play a bit on the ball but both are quality defenders.

[The Skipper 20,609]

I still think he is up there. Thought he was quality once again today. It is something that most fans seem to do in terms of being harsh on our players. Other fans and pundits see different. For instance earlier in the match, the commentator said something down the lines of "Cahill has really turned into an excellent all round CB". But basically giving him huge compliments.

Despite his flaws he is one of my favourite players. Think he is a quality CB. Reminds me of Koscielny. Both rash, like to play a bit on the ball but both are quality defenders.

Koscielny is one level up from Cahill I think. A lot more comfortable on the ball and a lot more proactive too. Faster as well.

[Stats 7,136]

Koscielny is one level up from Cahill I think. A lot more comfortable on the ball and a lot more proactive too. Faster as well.

I rate them about the same. Cahill times his tackles to perfection most times while Koscielny is a bit more rash and concedes penalties much more often.

[Nike 373]

Koscielny is one level up from Cahill I think. A lot more comfortable on the ball and a lot more proactive too. Faster as well.

I agree.

He gets vilified quite a bit, but Koscielny is probably the best 1v1 defender in the BPL and the most agressive (now that Luiz is not here)

[iseah100 5,612]

I agree.

He gets vilified quite a bit, but Koscielny is probably the best 1v1 defender in the BPL and the most agressive (now that Luiz is not here)

Azpi is a better 1 v 1 defender.

[OneMoSalah 8,883]

You don't have to be a world class player to be an amazing captain.. look at Roy Keane.

Roy Keane wasn't world class? I'm sorry this is the guy who was assigned to man mark Zinedine Zidane... fucking Zizou of all people... and did very, very well, nulifiying him which was a big big factor as to how United beat Juventus and got to the Champions League final. Roy Keane was definitely a world class footballer in those days.

Anyway about time Gary scored a goal....