I don´t even know about Malouda to be honest. Like Willian he was offensively a very inconsistent player, but never provided the workrate or balance like the brazilian. If I remember correctly his stats of the first two seasons aren´t any better than Willians, despite playing with the likes of Drogba and Anelka up top.
That being said the Malouda from March 09-October 2010 was easily better than Willian, but don´ t get me started on Maloudas form from Nov 2010 till he left Chelsea...