No doubt Tuchel had some solid results against those teams, but H2H only prove unique advantages. Over 38 games we see the team quality as a whole.
Pep and Klopp showed improvement every year, with Tuchel it is the opposite We were better in his first couple of months than we are now.
I don’t see Tuchel in the same realm as Pep and Klopp, I see those guys as visionary and club builders. Tuchel is more like Carlo, game day manager driven and focused.