Well, it is my opinion and I have my reasons why I do not rate Hummels as high as most of you do. For me, Subotic, before his injury, was better than Hummels in every aspect and their partnership made Hummels look like a world class player. The same way Boateng makes Hummels look like a solid defender when they both play for the national team. And frankly De Gea is the reason why United's defence has that record. They'd probably be on 40-45 goals conceded if it wasn't for him. He's been phenomenal this season and he is the main reason why they are challenging for a Champions League spot. Smalling, Jones, Evans, Valencia, Rojo - they are all average defenders that wouldn't even make the bench here. I'm not saying I am entirely right, but this is what I think. They got away with murder so many times this season because of De Gea's world class display.