It all depends on what you rate as better attributes. Like for some stamina shows the greatest athlete. I.e. Usain bolt and Mohammad Farah are both great athletes but completely different, in terms of top speeds agility strength stamina etc. Basketball players arn't as strong as NFL players etc, but have better stamina etc. I think Adrian Peterson, proportionately (i.e. without being extremely tall), is a great athlete, and definitely up there.