Okay, that's a valid opinion. But riddle me this: Would you think the same if he was a random Congolese player from Ligue 1, who had the same hype as Luke did a few years ago, then moved to a genuinely big team and hasn't produced a decent season since? Who hasn't broken through in that big team, who hasn't played over 20 games a season for 3 years due to serious injury problems and who has been criticized by different managers for attitude problems? I say stay away, we need an upgrade on Alonso, not a backup to a player who would ideally be backup to someone much better. Luke Shaw is not better and he will not play over Alonso if he came here, pointless. Also, going from Alex Sandro to Luke Shaw is like going from Messi to Andros Townsend, just so underwhelming. We need to aim higher, much higher, someone who can actually improve us.