Rumoured Luke Shaw

[Gilvorak 3,734]

23 isn't old but people need to recognise there's a reason why he's 23 and still not established in a top league. Similarly there's a reason why Shaw was a first-teamer in a Premier League side at 17 and it's not just because he was at Southampton.

Is Van Aanholt another player you're hoping will come back with his new team and destroy us then?

What a flawed way of thinking.

Van Aanholt isn't established in a Top League because he had Ashley Cole, Ryan Bertrand (who played in a CL final) and the £18m man Zhirkov in front of him not to mention the relentless managerial instability at the club. Since Carlo (who rated him left) AVB, Rafa Benitez & Jose have all been our managers at one point or another.

Regardless of the League he's playing in what's the undeniable truth is that PVA is extremely gifted offensively. More than Cole, Shaw, Bertrand etc. We won't know about his defense until he's tested here.

Think this was his debut. I distinctly remember him tearing Newcastle apart that season.

Matic suffered a similar fate yet 3 years later he's worth £20m+.

[Tomo 21,733]

Whats all this sudden hype about PVA? he may have pace and occasionally hit a beauty but his defending is cringeworthy, Leicester fans couldn't stand him and Martinez froze him out at Wigan after 3 games.

We got rid off Bosingwa, the last thing we need is the left back version.

[Tomo 21,733]

What a flawed way of thinking.

Van Aanholt isn't established in a Top League because he had Ashley Cole, Ryan Bertrand (who played in a CL final) and the £18m man Zhirkov in front of him not to mention the relentless managerial instability at the club. Since Carlo (who rated him left) AVB, Rafa Benitez & Jose have all been our managers at one point or another.

Regardless of the League he's playing in what's the undeniable truth is that PVA is extremely gifted offensively. More than Cole, Shaw, Bertrand etc. We won't know about his defense until he's tested here.

Think this was his debut. I distinctly remember him tearing Newcastle apart that season.

Matic suffered a similar fate yet 3 years later he's worth £20m+.

Was that in the Carling Cup when we conceded 4 and he let Nile Ranger in behind him for one of them?

Scoring and assisting one is pointless if you let in 4.

[Gilvorak 3,734]

Whats all this sudden hype about PVA? he may have pace and occasionally hit a beauty but his defending is cringeworthy, Leicester fans couldn't stand him and Martinez froze him out at Wigan after 3 games.

We got rid off Bosingwa, the last thing we need is the left back version.

http://www.cockneylatic.co.uk/fourm/5-cockney-latic-main-forum/76176-van-aanholt?limitstart=0

Quick google search and it looks like Wigan fans rated him but he had a personal falling out with Martinez.

Nevermind the fact that this was 3 years ago while he was still only 20.

[Gilvorak 3,734]

Was that in the Carling Cup when we conceded 4 and he let Nile Ranger in behind him for one of them?

Scoring and assisting one is pointless if you let in 4.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5a7-xsmCEdU

Watch the highlights yourself. He was at fault for Ranger's goal but the remaining 3 (Ryan Taylor FK, Paul Ferreira error, Bruma losing Ameobi on a set piece assignment) were hardly his fault. Besides we were down to 9 men for the majority of that game and were only a Ferreira shot that hit the post away from winning it.

[Tomo 21,733]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5a7-xsmCEdU

Watch the highlights yourself. He was at fault for Ranger's goal but the remaining 3 (Ryan Taylor FK, Paul Ferreira error, Bruma losing Ameobi on a set piece assignment) were hardly his fault. Besides we were down to 9 men for the majority of that game and were only a Ferreira shot that hit the post away from winning it.

I kept a close eye that night and yes only one off the goals were his doing i felt his positional sense was terrible even for someone his age.

The reason i kept a close eye that night is because like you now i liked his game going forward and wanted to see what he was like at the back.

Im usually against turning defenders into mids but maybe the Bale route might be worth considering with him?

[The Skipper 20,593]

Which is my point all along. why can't PVA be the exception as well? Besides his obvious talent, he's shown tons of improvement in his game and is regarded as arguably the best defender in that league. Some people are just unnecessarily closed minded and think football is that black and white.

He's definitely more matured in his game but he isn't as good as you're making him out to be. He's been very influential for Vitesse due to his great attacking ability and Vitesse's system of overlapping fullbacks but defensively he still gets found out, even in the Eredivisie. That's my main problem with him - I'm not very sure he's able to stay solid defensively in the PL. He's one of the better players but not the best because his defensive game isn't as complete as his attacking game.

If we are selling Bertrand I would like him back though. I wouldn't mind having something like Shaw/PVA as the LB options. Doubt the club are thinking along those lines though.

[The only place to be 11,313]

What a flawed way of thinking.

Van Aanholt isn't established in a Top League because he had Ashley Cole, Ryan Bertrand (who played in a CL final)

Bertrand played as a makeshift left-winger in the final.

Bosingwa also played in that final, as did a completely past-it Malouda....oh and we were a pretty poor team then.

Regardless of the League he's playing in what's the undeniable truth is that PVA is extremely gifted offensively. More than Cole, Shaw, Bertrand etc. We won't know about his defense until he's tested here.

He might be gifted in an attacking sense but he's 23 and you can't say whether or not he's got a good enough defence to be tried here. It's a gamble to not go for a talent like Shaw because you think a 23 year old who has never done a single remarkable thing on a decent stage might be good enough....

oh and here's a Youtube video of him doing well in a game in which we conceded 4 goals at home, lost and in which we used Gael Kakuta (shit, why did we sign Salah when we've still got Kakuta on our books???).

[Rmpr 8,977]

As for Shaw, he knows one day that we'll come knocking at his door. If hes as much of a Chelsea fan as people say he is, he will wait for us to.

That is not fair though, he doesnt have any moral obligation to wait for Chelsea only because he is a Chelsea fan!

I mean, he is still a professional at the end of the day and it is not always that a big transfer offer appears for a talented young LB (which has become rare nowadays). He cant have the luxury to turn down offer after offer waiting for Chelsea to one day decide to make a bid...What if he suffers an injury? What if he drops form? What if Southampton decide they need quick money? Etc.

Of course that if we do pursue him and he has the option to choose between us and another team, we will expect that he chooses us. But, in my opinion, no footballer has to wait for a team just because they support it!

[DavidEU 2,023]

That is not fair though, he doesn't have any moral obligation to wait for Chelsea only because he is a Chelsea fan!

I didn't say he did. I was answering those who are almost implying that we are automatically at the front of the queue for him. I meant that maybe its a case of Manchester United this summer or Chelsea the following, with a year of gaining experience with another club he loves in Southampton, maybe he'd favour us. Maybe.

He'll be top draw though. As will a lot of the Southampton talent.

[Korea 734]

Wasnt theo walcott a liverpool fan?

JT a Man United fan?

Also, todays game will be a good test for Shaw...

[peter_amb 54]

Shaw sets up southamptons first goal

[Milan 17,859]

Great, great cross. Now help your team keep clean sheet Luke!

[peter_amb 54]

Had a decent game today

[Rekin 835]

Brilliant game by Shaw. Got an assist and really worked well in the defense.
Whichever team gets him can feel very good about themselves.

[Korea 734]

Shaw really likes to bomb forward...

On a side note, Arsenal played terrible and still drew somehow...

[duo11bluecl 207]

Good game but no where near worth 30m, these are the sort of money being spent on Kompany, Thiago Silva, Ramos.

[Toli 977]

Good game but no where near worth 30m, these are the sort of money being spent on Kompany, Thiago Silva, Ramos.

LBs are much much rarer than CBs. futhermore he is english, which also plays on the price. and nearly every top club is rumoured to be after him. Even though I agree, that 20 m should be the maximum for Luke.

And he was amazing today.