Mate, I still have not read it yet, so I wont judge. I just think you should have waited until he had a game alongside a proper DM... EDIT: You see, most of the time Rambo and Oscar did not know who should have been the DM and CM. In Benitez Loserpool, one marked the opponents playmaker (CM, Xabi Alonso) and the other was the midfield space protector who stood in front of the center backs (DM, Mascherano). While attacking, Alonso played as a deep lying playmaker and Mascherano had a minor role, basically composing the midfield and providing help with short passes, runs and corner rebounds. With our double pivot, Ramires and Oscar were incrediblely confused. Sometimes Ramires was the DM in the defensive end but the CM while attacking and vice-versa, with Oscar either. In the first half, it was a mess (see the difference between the first and second picture). In the second half it got a bit better, see how Rambo was more fixed and closer to Luiz/Cahill and Oscar was participating in the build up play with a lot more mobility. However, apart from their confused role and positioning, their individual performances were great and with good intensity (just look at the stats). Since it was more of an emergency, I think this wasnt the game to be judging both of them. I bet they didnt even trained together! In the end, your observations were good though.