Aaron Anselmino

[ZAPHOD2319 4,525]

 

[TheHulk 1,892]

Good potential, hope he has a good season on loan.

[robsblubot 3,539]

He does not look like a physical Cb, which might be a good thing if he's really good on the ball as well as reading of the game. Best of luck.

[OneMoSalah 8,788]

8 hours ago, robsblubot said:

He does not look like a physical Cb, which might be a good thing if he's really good on the ball as well as reading of the game. Best of luck.

If he is really good on the ball but is going to really struggle physically, thats not a lot of use is it?

People tend to overlook everything now for if someone is good on the ball. Two sides to football, with and without the ball.

Hopefully being South American he has a bit of an aggressiveness about him similarly to Romero at Spurs and Martinez at United, just toned down a bit. Will help if he isn’t particularly physically well developed but he will need to improve on the physicality, there are not many good central defenders now without that side of the game.

Edited July 31, 2024 by OneMoSalah

[nyikolajevics 2,596]

1 hour ago, OneMoSalah said:

If he is really good on the ball but is going to really struggle physically, thats not a lot of use is it?

People tend to overlook everything now for if someone is good on the ball. Two sides to football, with and without the ball.

Hopefully being South American he has a bit of an aggressiveness about him similarly to Romero at Spurs and Martinez at United, just toned down a bit. Will help if he isn’t particularly physically well developed but he will need to improve on the physicality, there are not many good central defenders now without that side of the game.

Christensen is a skinny guy too, but he is doing quite well on the highest level of football.

Also he 18 only, we still have time to fed him with some extra oatmeal for breakfast. Look at Kompany when he was at Hamburg as a youngster, he got much more built in years at City.

[Wise Old Man 38]

Muscle mass doesn’t always correlate with strength anyway 

[OneMoSalah 8,788]

4 hours ago, nyikolajevics said:

Christensen is a skinny guy too, but he is doing quite well on the highest level of football.

Also he 18 only, we still have time to fed him with some extra oatmeal for breakfast. Look at Kompany when he was at Hamburg as a youngster, he got much more built in years at City.

True but Christensen also filled out a bit. Its not re the size for me, physically wanting to engage players is as much mental as it is physical. Get the concept, I am not saying he has to be absolutely stacked but if your a central defender and you struggle with physicality it is a big issue.

4 hours ago, Wise Old Man said:

Muscle mass doesn’t always correlate with strength anyway 

Again as said above, its more the aspect of if he struggles physically that is a issue for me. Does he mean that he doesn’t like engaging players in duels etc? Doesn’t like contact with players?
 

 

[robsblubot 3,539]

9 hours ago, OneMoSalah said:

If he is really good on the ball but is going to really struggle physically, thats not a lot of use is it?

People tend to overlook everything now for if someone is good on the ball. Two sides to football, with and without the ball.

Hopefully being South American he has a bit of an aggressiveness about him similarly to Romero at Spurs and Martinez at United, just toned down a bit. Will help if he isn’t particularly physically well developed but he will need to improve on the physicality, there are not many good central defenders now without that side of the game.

I think the missing piece of the puzzle here is the system. In that positional game the defenders have to be very mobile and good on the ball; pace and skill are more important than physicality as you can see City's defense line. I'm suggesting that he's very much a Maresca signing.

I used to hear the same about Stones, even though I always rated him. I could totally see Stones not doing as well in a low block direct system (say England eh), but he does a really good job for City.

Edited July 31, 2024 by robsblubot

[OneMoSalah 8,788]

6 hours ago, robsblubot said:

I think the missing piece of the puzzle here is the system. In that positional game the defenders have to be very mobile and good on the ball; pace and skill are more important than physicality as you can see City's defense line. I'm suggesting that he's very much a Maresca signing.

I used to hear the same about Stones, even though I always rated him. I could totally see Stones not doing as well in a low block direct system (say England eh), but he does a really good job for City.

But Dias, Stones, Walker, Ake, Gvardiol are all aggressive and willing to go into physical duals and can deal with that also.

Yes reading the game I get that is essential for these types of defenders but these guys also need to have that aggression and willingness to engage and compete with people physically.

Edited July 31, 2024 by OneMoSalah

[robsblubot 3,539]

1 hour ago, OneMoSalah said:

But Dias, Stones, Walker, Ake, Gvardiol are all aggressive and willing to go into physical duals and can deal with that also.

Yes reading the game I get that is essential for these types of defenders but these guys also need to have that aggression and willingness to engage and compete with people physically.

I guess you can say they are all very pacy, but I don't consider them powerful... maybe Walker but he's hardly the one who stays back.
Aggression is a mental skill, not physical. Kante is full of aggression and he's a tiny guy.

My take on the D of the positional game, is that pace and skill on the ball are the new requirements. Pace for both the high line and to close down aggressively; skill on the ball is important for keeping possession from the back. That does not mean they shouldn't be able to defend, but only that there are new requirements at play.

All academic of course; he's 18 and will develop into his own player. Suppose we will find out when he returns from loan.

[ZAPHOD2319 4,525]

 

[ZAPHOD2319 4,525]

I was reading that he is rated the highest CB in South America. Not really sure what that means…potential or current performance? 
 

 

[DH1988 1,317]

Wow, big decision there, wonder if it means we're going to see a CB or two leave *cough* Disasi + Bada*cough*, though I will say Colwill hasn't covered himself in glory this year. May seem harsh and yes I know we're learning as a team, doing very well vs expectations/progress but he has not impressed me at all this season, positionally so as well, distribution aside.

Cannot claim to have seen anything of this lad beyond the typical 'Welcome to Chelsea Random Player' compilation, as I read in another thread someone said that the scouts deserve credit, and they do, so I'll continue to trust their judgement.

[ZAPHOD2319 4,525]

I think the most I have seen about him is in this thread.

 

[Mhsc 922]

1 hour ago, DH1988 said:

though I will say Colwill hasn't covered himself in glory this year. May seem harsh and yes I know we're learning as a team, doing very well vs expectations/progress but he has not impressed me at all this season, positionally so as well, distribution aside.

In my opinion Colwill is the worst defender and biggest liability from our best XI - he for sure deserves to be in the XI, because of the low quality we have at CB right now, but he is the worst of that XI imo.

Any normal top team would have him out on loan still - he's 21, and does not have high football IQ or defensive ability (tackling / positioning / decision making). Everything will be fixed with time - his ceiling is probably not THAT high given he clearly lacks football IQ but in his mid 20s I expect he will be a very decent PL CB because experience will paper over the cracks to a decent extent, and his ball playing ability will carry him (especially if he adds better decision making there too - he could become a menace).

Question remains should we be bedding these guys in directly at Chelsea or not. The clubs view clearly is in the end it is better to do it and let them develop and bond with the rest of the squad. I can see the merits of that.

[King Kante 1,504]

On 30/12/2024 at 23:43, ZAPHOD2319 said:

I was reading that he is rated the highest CB in South America. Not really sure what that means…potential or current performance? 
 

 

Yeah, there is only so much of the Disaster Bros (Disaster and Tosin) we can watch. I think it is clear that the club were thinking of having him out on loan for the year but as he will likely walk into the team here if he is half decent, he may as well come back. Hopefully Disaster is shipped out. He isn't even squad filler level. 

Edited yesterday at 15:33 by King Kante