Alex

[chrismada9 1,948]

How about £40 million + Alex for Sergio Aguero

or we keep Alex, it's their choice really

[warnie_666 1,081]

Alex can Go. We have Mancienne and Bane as back up. Carvalho will be 31 next season, and Ivanovic can take his place fulltime in couple of seasons.

[BlueLion. 21,491]

I'd sell Carvalho tbh. He's not getting any younger and is persistently injured. As much as I love the player, there's a time when every player can be replaced. I personally rate Alex as a defender who is just as good as Carvalho, in all honesty.

[Kez 2,727]

I agree, reluctantly Alex can replace Carvalho and do a good job plus we have Mancienne. However i hope Carvalho has a couple years left

[warnie_666 1,081]

I'd sell Carvalho tbh. He's not getting any younger and is persistently injured. As much as I love the player, there's a time when every player can be replaced. I personally rate Alex as a defender who is just as good as Carvalho, in all honesty.

How do you rate both same?

Carvalho is a pacy defender who does the dirt work. Alex is typicaly a very similar defender to JT and lacks pace. Ivanovic is another Pacy Defender. Since JT cannot be replaced, Id replace Alex.

[Badboy 1,526]

How do you rate both same?

Carvalho is a pacy defender who does the dirt work. Alex is typicaly a very similar defender to JT and lacks pace. Ivanovic is another Pacy Defender. Since JT cannot be replaced, Id replace Alex.

Warnie you have to look at age as well carvalho is our best defender but also the oldest. Ivanovic is young and pacy and so is mancienne alex is 26 and a monster. So its hard but i would say sell carvalho for 8 million and get a young pacy forward like henri saviet. Then use branislav and terry as the centre backs next season.

Next season !

Mancienne (21 years old) Alex da costa (26 years old)

Branislav ivanovic (25 years old) John terry (28 years old)

This will give us the correct blend of pace power and age. Sorry carvalho your the odd one out.

Edited April 13, 2009 by Badboy

[BlueLion. 21,491]

How do you rate both same?

Carvalho is a pacy defender who does the dirt work. Alex is typicaly a very similar defender to JT and lacks pace. Ivanovic is another Pacy Defender. Since JT cannot be replaced, Id replace Alex.

They're different defenders, but they have their own strengths. Carvalho is faster and has better positional judgement, but Alex is stronger and better aerially.

[Matterz 67]

I have to agree that perhaps it is time to let go of Riccy, his age and his injuries make it very difficult for him to be consistent when he does play. Dont get me wrong he is one of the best players we have ever had but it would just be such a shame to let go of either Alex or Ivanovic who will be world class players to keep Carvalho for another 2 or 3 years if even that. Remember we have Mancienne as well so it just really makes a lot of sense that we let Riccy go to me

[the wes 7,212]

I have to agree that perhaps it is time to let go of Riccy, his age and his injuries make it very difficult for him to be consistent when he does play. Dont get me wrong he is one of the best players we have ever had but it would just be such a shame to let go of either Alex or Ivanovic who will be world class players to keep Carvalho for another 2 or 3 years if even that. Remember we have Mancienne as well so it just really makes a lot of sense that we let Riccy go to me

you forgot about Slobodan Rajković!!!!!!!

[SystemBlueBob 0]

His goal tonight was really, imo, the complete slap towards Liverpool that we needed

An absolutely beautiful, hard shot towards the corner

Really shut the door on their hopes

[5354 204]

Alex is a good back up.... not always consistent....

[BlueLion. 21,491]

I don't give a fuck, when you can hit a freekick like that, you earn your wages

[Kez 2,727]

We cant get rid of someone that can do that!

[SystemBlueBob 0]

I don't give a fuck, when you can hit a freekick like that, you earn your wages

Amen to that. I am not sure i was as DAMN PUMPED as I was when he drilled that kick in the goal!

[the wes 7,212]

Manchester City are ready to go back to Chelsea to boost their defensive stocks.

But it won't be for skipper John Terry, instead, City are eyeing a bid for Chelsea's Brazil international defender Alex.

The Times says City will move for Alex if they fail to prise Joleon Lescott away from Everton.

[We Hate Scouse 10,286]

There having a laugh aren't they! They can fuck right off.

[thejolta 1]

Hahahahahhaahahahahahaahahaha

[5354 204]

15M TO 20M will be nice.

TBH, we can actually sell Alex.