lucio

Watch a compilation of his debut It’s littered with heavy / poor touches. He just outpaced an ancient James Milner a few times 

Sorry, but a highlights clip isn't going to change my mind. I see him week in, week out down the bridge and see things that do not always come across on TV. As @robsblubotsays, he is a good ball winner but he lacks skills on the ball.
Personally, I do not have him in the Disas(ter)i category yet where I am saying that he shouldn't be anywhere near the first XI ever - although he for sure should've been dropped at times this season -it is more that I just don't see him as a DM/CM that teams that want to win things need. Furthermore, I don't see how he develops that side of the game as typically with players that explode, they have the technical side then explode physically which adds another dimension to their game.
Maybe Caicedo gets stronger physically and, with that, becomes almost unplayable in his recovery of the ball, however he isn't - imo - going to become a midfield of sufficient technical ability to take a team to the league title or anything like that - for sure he may be part of a team to do so, but he will be a secondary part of the starting XI rather than a main man.

He’s decent , I don’t think he’ll be more than a squad option in a team chasing the big trophies but he’s got hustle and way more useful than mudryk on the other flank , still question marks over attitude.
hutchinson has a higher ceiling imo tho 

Below players need to get sold without any shadow of a doubt:
Sterling
Chilwell
Disasi
Sanchez
Rest still have room for debate but these 4 need to be thrown out useless.

He’s decent , I don’t think he’ll be more than a squad option in a team chasing the big trophies but he’s got hustle and way more useful than mudryk on the other flank , still question marks over attitude.
hutchinson has a higher ceiling imo tho 

Amorim is much less of a gamble than potter. 
less of a gamble than Pochettino too , if the goal is to actually win something and not just be a steady decent club 

That game and the cup final fucked our season 

Sanchez showed the whole world what a pathetic loser he is against Arsenal and his loser coach started him the next match like nothing happened. Fuck Poch.

Can’t win a trophy gift wrapped for him but can turn on the form to save his job before proceeding to stink up another season. Complete fraud 

Once he is over his hernia and we sack Poch, he will look like a total different player.

Keep him! 
Get this man a proper defense. 

There's improvement and that's the more important part for me. We are not going to win anything soon. So it's best to build a good team. 
Let's keep him and fix the defense and keep marching upward. 

To be fair I can’t remember Belgium having a great game themselves. They wasted a golden generation on Wilmots and Martinez. 

For sure , if we picked him up for 30m he probably wouldn’t get much criticism but for a record breaking fee... I think it was onemosalah who said for that money for a midfielder you need to be getting an elite goal scorer or playmaker 

yup and tbf to Caicedo, if we remove the price tag from the equation, he's a decent potentially good player. Of course we overpaid big time, but that's our modus operandi these days eh.

For just a decent ball winner without serious skill or physicality you could have got so many similar players for way cheaper 

Yeah I think he lacks more than a he physical aspects actually. One could argue that a WC should already look pretty impressive at 22.
honestly eyeballs only here, he simply lacks skill. He’s pretty lousy past the midfield line, for ex.
Why "past the midfield line is different"? it's more contested and there is less space to operate--better players thrive there.

Heh I know right?! Some people really get attached to the players for some reason.
players come and go there is no fucking loyalty in the game. They usually last a little longer than managers, but they always go. I highly recommend meeting a professional football and actually talking to him; their mindset would look strangely familiar to us grinders 😆 
there is nothing special about caicedo. Kante used to do what he does 10x better. Imagining that because he’s young he will get to WC is just wishful thinking. The truth is that none of us know that, we just have guesses. Mine is that there is no evidence to support the case caicedo will be WC one day. 

You’re getting pressed because someone has different opinions about football players 

Even hudson odoi is way better than mudryk 

Sterling is garbage and needs binning. 

Sterling is garbage and needs binning. 

Hutchinson shits all over mudryk 

Arsenal with the classic “penalty just before half time trope” massive frauds 

Madueke could potentially be a nice backup , mudryk doesn’t belong at this level and needs offloading unfortunately