Rather than being a Torres 2.0, I think Rooney will be RVP 2.0 edit: Tomo, you make a good case for Yilmaz but the last point about English experience this point will never go Yilmaz's way. 2 contradicting examples - Torres and SWP - can't swing this one away from Rooney Signing a PL-proven player is far safer/better than signing a good player from an inferior league