Miroslav Stoch Vs Scott Sinclair

[the wes 7,212]

That's take this to the poll who's the best player????

[EskWeston 696]

I would have to say Stoch. Only because he more all rounded than Sinclair. Sinclair is faster and arguably a better finisher than Stoch. But Stoch has incredible ball skills and his final ball, not to mention free kicks is excellant. He is also very quick and a great finisher himself which is why i would put him ahead of Sinclair.

Also Stoch has pushed on massively in the last couple of seasons whereas Sinclair seems to have stagnated somewhat.

Just as an afternote i would mention that Kakuta has the ability and potential to be better than Stoch!

[BlueLion. 21,491]

Having seen more of Sinclair than I have of Stoch, it was only natural for me to go for Scott rather than Miroslav, although both are excellent players and in them we have a pair of top quality players.

[Elliott 7]

From what I've seen of both players, Stoch is the better player. Sinclair has struggled to make a real impact in games when he's played for us, whereas Stoch came on against Stoke and basically inspired us to victory.

[Badboy 1,526]

Stoch same reason's as esk more rounded player by far.

[warnie_666 1,081]

I go with Blue Lion on this. Have seen more of Scott and less of Stoch, so I go for Scott.

P.S: Is Kakuta a midfielder pr a winger.

We seem to have only Wingers coming to the fore.

[Steve 10,227]

Myself i would have to go with Stoch, don't get me wrong Sinclair is a great asset to our team as well but when Stoch came onto the pitch on the weekend he basically changed the game, for a young kid to have the impact he did on the game he has got a good future with the club.

[BlueLion. 21,491]

I think people forget Sinclair's performance last season against Hull, and also against Huddersfield. The two big chances he got last season, and in those two games, he scored and got a couple of assists. I'm waiting for Stoch to impress me so.

[warnie_666 1,081]

I think people forget Sinclair's performance last season against Hull, and also against Huddersfield. The two big chances he got last season, and in those two games, he scored and got a couple of assists. I'm waiting for Stoch to impress me so.

Add Arsenal Away performance.

[Mungii 3]

Having seen more of Sinclair than I have of Stoch, it was only natural for me to go for Scott rather than Miroslav, although both are excellent players and in them we have a pair of top quality players.

I must say just the same thing....but I hope that we will have them both in next years!

[BlueLion. 21,491]

Add Arsenal Away performance.

Correct, going back to the tail end of 06/07, also, he had some good performances under JM.

[Alee. 182]

I need to see a bit more of Stoch.. Though if i judge on the performance he gave at Stoke then Stoch is world class which he obviously isnt (yet anyway) . Hes got alot of potential and i hope we can groom him right.

[bombayblue™ 55]

My only source is from the youth and reserve game videos that esk puts up on youtube... i go for stoch simple cos i got more than what i expected when he came on against stoke in a desperate situation..

[PaulHopkins 1]

Stoch for me!

[warnie_666 1,081]

Stoch for me looks more of an Impact player while Sinclair looks like one who could play the entire 90 mins.

I cant forget his preformance at arsenal Away in a 10 man Chelsea side against 12 man Arsenal Side, in the most important game of the season.

I am just baffled he hasnt got any good opportunities after that.

[EskWeston 696]

Sinclair has been hindered by sporadic first team appearances, moved around on loan and then we clung onto him for the Home grown quota when a season long loan at a good club would have been more beneficial to him. Unfortunately i don't think we have handled him too well. Going through 3 managers hasn't helped either but it certainly affected Sinclair, and unfortunately Stoch has developed above Sinclair now.