If a Winger is to be sold - who should it be?

[Elliott 7]

Both wingers seem to have done alright in pre-season so far. I wouldn't be too upset if we kept them both, but if we do bring in Robinho one of them has to go and I'd prefer it to be Shauny just because he's been here longer and not proven himself whereas I'm willing to give Malouda the benefit of the doubt over last season.

[BlueLion. 21,491]

Keeping them both would not be such a bad thing in my opinion. I prefer Malouda because I know he has a huge amount of talent. It is only a matter of time before he recaptures his form at Lyon.

[GodisnowhereCFC 0]

Wow this is tough one, I picked Malouda to go and Small Wright-Phillips to stay. SWP has heart and years of training and playing with the rest of the lads. Malouda often looks unaggressive, and lacks the heart required to play in the EPL (I would love to see this change, but you never know).

[CFC-Lloydy 38]

Malouda can kindly leave, over ickle Shauny!

[Joe Cool 388]

SWP can fuck off. He hasn't improved at all from what I've seen in preseason. Malouda has, on the other hand

[cfc-meleady 192]

Wright-Phillips,i just don't think he has the ability to be playing with a top premier league club.

Although he would be a great signing for most clubs below the top 4.

[BlueLion. 21,491]

Malouda is the better player. At Lyon, he was arguably one of the best wingers in Europe. He needed time to settle, like Ballack, like Drogba, like everyone. However, some people just can't accept the fact that professional footballers actually are human and therefore need time. So like Ballack, and like Drogba, he'll be an improved man next year. I don't see why SWP should be given a fourth year after failing to impress whilst Malouda has had only one.

[changingman2000 35]

Malouda, Because I think he's a cunt.

[Gianfranco_Z 202]

Care to elaborate?

[Guest Lampards Bitch]

Malouda is shite. He seems to like Pre-seasons and thats it. The guy drives me to the point of disraction. Shaun did play very well when given a chance last season imo. Hoping he will get more oppourtunities in this coming season.

[Para6iT 2]

I think swp are more talented than malouda. But we still can give him(malouda) a chance.

[Gianfranco_Z 202]

I don't see why SWP should be given a fourth year after failing to impress whilst Malouda has had only one.

I think that pretty much nails it.

[mastiffchild 1]

Whoa!?? We have a winger? I thought that went out the window when Duffer and Robben left, didn't it?

SWP isn't a footballer atall, Malouda doen't want to be even though he's shown he could(though more of a left sided Becks than winger even at his Lyon best). Joey is no wonger and Sally Kally is a second striker played wide because he pulls that way as he models his game on Henry.

Sinclair is right footed and is played on the left which counts him out(also better eventually as a striker).

Stoch, though , is a winger of sorts so that's about it. One reserve winger who won't play. And Kakuta isn't a winger either-should be good though.

EDIT:should we sign Robinho he isn't one either.

Edited August 8, 2008 by mastiffchild

[valim 0]

if one player can't improve 4 years when he can improve

swp should sell

malouda play realy good with scolari

[mastiffchild 1]

Wright-Phillips,i just don't think he has the ability to be playing with a top premier league club.

Although he would be a great signing for most clubs below the top 4.

Below the top four leagues/age groups?