These stats do not prove that Higuain is more clinical than Aguero. Minutes-per-goal ratio/ Number of goals scored per match does NOT prove that one player is more clinical than the others. In order to prove that I don't have to go for some different sources; I will use your own sources. http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2011/nov/02/premier-league-top-goals-scorers#zoomed-picture According to that article, Minutes-per-goal ratio of Edin Dzeko is far less than that of Messi, Mario Gomez, Ronaldo, and even Van Persie's. Does that mean Dzeko is more clinical/better finisher than those players? I don't think so. In order to know who is more clinical, we will have to see number of goals scored from number of good chances they get.