I see your point mate and I may have not explained mine well so let me try again. The examples I gave in my previous post and the statement you mentioned about Germans and penalties are not "bad" because they don't insult anyone. But my point is I'd rather say something like "Most German players are excellent at penalties" because: 1) "Germans never loose penalties" is a logical fallacy. 2) I ask again: Why do you feel the need to over-generalize a trait, especially among a race? There are 1.5 million professional footballers in Germany (I read this number once but I'm not too sure about it), how many of them have you watched? 1000? 10000? For all you know, the vast majority of German footballers could be terrible at penalties. Same goes for black people and rapping. Rapping became trendy in some areas in the US that contain societies that are mostly made of black people. The actual ability to rap has nothing to do with skin color as I'm sure there are millions and millions of black people in Africa who can't rap. Why people feel the need to make a connection between rapping and skin color is honestly beyond me. 3) The dangerous part of these statements is the mentality behind them. You say that black people (in the US) are good at rapping because there are more rappers with black skin. If, at one point, there are more black or white people in jail, does that justify saying that this race or that race are criminals? The problem is "Black people are good rappers" and other similar sentences are one step away from "Black people criminals", "Arabs are terrorists", "The Irish are alchoholic"...etc I'm sorry I just can't see the logic behind that, can you elaborate? And why can't someone say that a person of his own race is racist? I say that regularly to people of my own race who use the words "Black" and "Slave" interchangeably (an unfortunate and ignorant part of the evolution of the Lebanese dialogue that is thankfully becoming rarer)