I mean, when Jose left.. If we were offered this: 6 Points away from the league leaders.. Carling Cup Semi Final... Champions League Knockout Round FA Cup 3rd Round..! I mean i would have took it.. And what if you were offered, League Leaders Realistic chance of winning the league Confidence that jose inspired even when facing barcelona with hilario in goal Now which one would you take, The thing is Grant has done better than what we expected to do cos we thought jose was everything and him leaving meant doom for our club.. We (including me) overreacted.. Try thinking what position we would have been had jose still been around or a competent manger was in charge.. most of the hate for grant comes from his appointment as director of football and suddenly we don't need one now.. making it even more certain how the exile of jose was planned.. i dont hate grant, but i don't love him or rate him either..