A few questions

[Tomo 21,733]

Evening fellow Blues, there has been a few things that has been bugging me for some time and hoping you have the answers for them.

If Liverpool won the league in 08/09, would Robbie Keane have got a medal despite getting sold in January?

When Watford were relegated in 06/07, did Ashley Young get the relegation on his CV despite leaving for Villa half way through?

When we won the FA Cup under Hiddink, did Scolari get a medal as he oversaw our 1st 3 games in that competition, and would he have got a medal if we won the CL that year (as he oversaw our group stage progress)?

[Ollie 4,400]

I'm guessing no, no and no because i'm sure the player must be there when the moment happens. You need 10 appearances to get a premiership medal but you must still be with the club because if u leave, you didn't technically win the league with that team, you were just top or 2nd, w/e. The same with relegation, you were just in bottom place. Scolari wouldn't get an FA Cup winners medal for winning in the 4th round or whatever it was. Guus picked the final winning team.

I can understand your curiosity but if you think about it, the answer is quite or should be quite obvious and simple.

[Shane 2,275]

Keane would have got a medal because he played more than 10 games, He said in the Irish press if Liverpool won the league he would give his medal to his brother who is a Liverpool fan.

[Madmax 9,219]

1. Keane would have, yes. He'd made the required 10 appearances.

2. No.

3. No.

[spuz 143]

Keane would have got a medal because he played more than 10 games, He said in the Irish press if Liverpool won the league he would give his medal to his brother who is a Liverpool fan.

That's probably the most stupid rule i've heard.

In 2005,Scott Parker,Forsell and Cudicini didn't receive winners medals.

I wonder if anybody has left a team that went on to be champions and received a winners medal ?