One player you would take from a Premier League team

[Madmax 9,219]

Meh. Can Park significantly improve our main weakness, lack of creativity?I seriously doubt that

Probably not in the conventional sense, no. And that's not why I want him anyway because we've got Mata and possibly Modric for that. With those two in the side you need someone to 'bust a gut' ... do the dirty work of ensuring that things keep ticking over and the engine room functions with discipline.

-------------------Torres------------

---------------------------------------Sturridge---

-----Mata--------------------------------------

-----------Park----Modric-----Ramires----

Cole--------Terry------Alex-------Ivan----

[DYC. 7,542]

Have to agree with styles and say Silva.

I disagree with Messi being the best of this generation personally on top form Fat Ronaldo pisses all over any-one ive personally ever seen.

They're not of the same generation though.

My answer is obvious: David F*cking Silva.

Though a in-form Wayne Rooney is a very, very close second. Rooney needs to show he can keep his current form for a whole season.

And the third place goes to Vincent Kompany, what a player.

[lionsden 4,689]

Probably not in the conventional sense, no. And that's not why I want him anyway because we've got Mata and possibly Modric for that. With those two in the side you need someone to 'bust a gut' ... do the dirty work of ensuring that things keep ticking over and the engine room functions with discipline.

-------------------Torres------------

---------------------------------------Sturridge---

-----Mata--------------------------------------

-----------Park----Modric-----Ramires----

Cole--------Terry------Alex-------Ivan----

I see your point. To an extent I feel Ramires is similar to Park in that regard. don't you think?. even though his energy level has dropped slightly since returning from Copa America. I agree with you on the importance of a workaholic in the team though.

[DYC. 7,542]

Oh lol of course, silly me. Messi is the best player of his generation. I laugh when people compare him with Ronaldo and ask who is the best.

Ronaldo has changed so much over the years. He is now just an athlete who runs in straight lines and shoots on sight. He lost all his magic and flair.

So true. Messi's just.. I don't know how to describe that guy in words. Cristiano has a crazy goal-scoring record but other than that, I've seen better.

[Madmax 9,219]

I see your point. To an extent I feel Ramires is similar to Park in that regard. don't you think?. even though his energy level has dropped slightly since returning from Copa America. I agree with you on the importance of a workaholic in the team though.

He is to an extent, yes. But personally I'm not a fan of the destroyer we employ in our 4-3-3 midfield. Mikel usually plays that strict defensive role and I think it takes away more than what it gives to the team. A creator in Modric, a shuttler in Ramires and another one of his ilk in Park would be more progressive than a simple destroyer like Mikel.

[manpe 10,861]

Silva... the spanish trio of Torres, Mata and Silva would destroy and piss on everybody. Modric comes close second. Rooney would also be class, but he's a cunt.

[Madmax 9,219]

And the third place goes to Vincent Kompany, what a player.

Good choice - possibly the outstanding centre-half in Europe atm, alongwith Thiago Silva.

[zolayes 14,489]

Wayne Rooney without a doubt. He makes Man Utd thick and would vastly improve our team. sometimes I feel he's more of a playmaker/attacking midfielder than a striker.

Honorable mention: Kompany, Silva and Van persie (if he can manage to stay injury free that is)

a lot of good choices there ...for me Rooney...team player 100%

[zolayes 14,489]

Most games. First name on the sheet in crunch matches.

Im just pleased you arent advising Roman

[Ramox 246]

Vermaelen.... He is the best CB all over the world in my opinion. He and Terry would be untouchable.

[Styles 9,790]

Im just pleased you arent advising Roman

Haha, well said. Park! Still amazed. I think Max is trying to go for an alternative option just to come off a little more enlightened than us chaps who want goals! :champions:

[Tomo 21,733]

Vermaelen.... He is the best CB all over the world in my opinion. He and Terry would be untouchable.

He never seems to handle the big occasion, Chelsea, United and Barca have made him look like a schoolkid in the past.

[Bir_CFC 3,455]

Tevez for me. Would say Rooney but I can't pick Man U scum for anything.

[Madmax 9,219]

Haha, well said. Park! Still amazed. I think Max is trying to go for an alternative option just to come off a little more enlightened than us chaps who want goals! :champions:

First you create a topic and ask for people's opinions, then ridicule those that don't match yours

[DYC. 7,542]

Good choice - possibly the outstanding centre-half in Europe atm, alongwith Thiago Silva.

They would form the perfect CB duo.

I've always had a weak spot for Anderson btw but he's been so inconsistent over the years (and he used to be a terrible shooter). It seems like those days are behind though.

[zolayes 14,489]

Haha, well said. Park! Still amazed. I think Max is trying to go for an alternative option just to come off a little more enlightened than us chaps who want goals! :champions:

well Park played 8 mins tonight ,,,dont think any against West Brom ,,,,SAF doesn't know what he is doing

[Styles 9,790]

Yeah okay, if you're just going to ridicule someone's opinion, why create create a topic and ask for them in the first place?

Park though! I think you've bought too much into the hype spread by Utd fans/media that he is some must-have, quality footballer.

He looked good against us last year because we were so sh*t! Barcelona ran rings around him in the final. Where was all that hard-worker stuff when facing quality? He was made to look the painfully avergae player that he is by a good team, probably the only good team they faced last year because no Premier League team was worth sh*t including us.

[Styles 9,790]

well Park played 8 mins tonight ,,,dont think any against West Brom ,,,,SAF doesn't know what he is doing

He only plays against decent opposition when Utd want to shut up shop and play on the counter. Why would you ever want that sort of player when you can have any player that you want? And even for that role De Jong is 10x better.