Question regarding "Reported speech", please help. :)

[Melanicus 5,208]

So, you have to put "When does your class finish?" into reported speech.

In book, the solution is: She asked me when my class finished.

But I personally would write: She asked me when did my class finish.

Is my version wrong?

Edit: I didn't know where to put it, so I posted it here.

[Sheva. 5,373]

Both are correct. You can just rename this to 'the homework thread' lol.

[CHOULO19 24,332]

Both are correct. You can just rename this to 'the homework thread' lol.

As far as I know, the second version is grammatically wrong because you are forming a sentence in the form of a question (verb before subject). But I could be wrong. Been years since I took grammar.

[The Skipper 20,593]

As far as I know, the second version is grammatically wrong because you are forming a sentence in the form of a question (verb before subject).

This.

[Heisenberg 1,824]

Shit, I'm also learning this shit this year.Not really learning, in someway.

Anyway, I think Choulo is right.First is better.

Its you who posted the same question in yahoo questions ?

[Rmpr 8,977]

This reminds so much of high school, lmao. Good times!

I second what Choulo said...

[CHOULO19 24,332]

Alright, did a little search and I'm 99% sure that the book's version is the only right one.

[xPetrCechx 13,563]

She asked me when my class finished.

[Sheva. 5,373]

Alright, did a little search and I'm 99% sure that the book's version is the only right one.

Yeah i was going to say just use the book answer lol, i repeated the 2nd one several times in my head sounded right, but you're right about all the grammar shit which i never paid attention to in school

[Melanicus 5,208]

Shit, I'm also learning this shit this year.Not really learning, in someway.

Anyway, I think Choulo is right.First is better.

Its you who posted the same question in yahoo questions ?

What mate?

Edit: Thanks everyone

[Rmpr 8,977]

Yeah i was going to say just use the book answer lol, i repeated the 2nd one several times in my head sounded right, but you're right about all the grammar shit which i never paid attention to in school

Foreigner students are so much better at grammar than native speakers, it is frustrating!

It happens in every language...

[Heisenberg 1,824]

What mate?

Edit: Thanks everyone

Nothing important, I found the same question on another site, but the thread has been deleted since.

Foreigner students are so much better at grammar than native speakers, it is frustrating!

It happens in every language...

100 % Right.

[CHOULO19 24,332]

Foreigner students are so much better at grammar than native speakers, it is frustrating!

It happens in every language...

LOL so true. I am terrible at Arabic grammar. Although, in my defense, it is probably the most complicated in the world.

[Heisenberg 1,824]

LOL so true. I am terrible at Arabic grammar. Although, in my defense, it is probably the most complicated in the world.

ما أحلى التكلم بثلاث لغات او اربع

[Melanicus 5,208]

Nothing important, I found the same question on another site, but the thread has been deleted since.

100 % Right.

I don't know, I don't even have yahoo account probably someone from my class?

[Heisenberg 1,824]

I don't know, I don't even have yahoo account probably someone from my class?

Your class is full of geeks & lazy persons that will surely not try to search any other response that the one on the book, so, you are the master there, no ?

[CHOULO19 24,332]

ما أحلى التكلم بثلاث لغات او اربع

Well that's easy to write. Try putting all the proper 'movements' (I didn't know how else to translate that! ) on the letters!

[Heisenberg 1,824]

We call that "tachkill' "التشكيل"

Actually, we never do the "movements" now, its almost impossible when you are listening and writing in the same time, it will demand a huge time to write perfectly and its isnt necessary because most of persons will understand without.