I don't know. He is adored by Liverpool fans because he was such a great player and because of what happened after Hillsborough, but his rumoured dodgy connections (re the Paul Stretford and Rooney affair in 2004) and the way he hung around at Liverpool like a vulture during the Benitez and Hodgson eras and managed to maintain a friendship with Christian Purslow while getting no flack for his association with this hated figure ... something about the man just doesn't ring true. Yet there's no doubt he's loving being the manager of Liverpool again and with the pressure off (now there are no expectations on them to win the title or the champion's league) and the help of Steve Clarke he seems to be doing a good job.