Juan Mata

[1chelsea 864]

Now days teams find your weakness and use it against you mata is a weak spot in any team he play Jose wanted more and think he can do with those weak spot if he play against them. He really a tactician always try to improve/raise his game

[meetdoscar 335]

Mata isn't ronaldo or messi u know he was loved but has been replaced already by oscar and willian in a stronger squad than before with hazard also having great evolution. Wish him well

[Shane 2,275]

RvP isn't known for using his strength. He manages with his technique - control of the ball.

Raul - not quick or strong. Champions League all time record goal scorer.

Raul and RVP are quite tall though, compared to Juan. A problem with Mata was that he is too easy pushed off the ball.

Mata signing is painting over United's cracks. You need 2 or 3 new midfielders and, In my opinion, a whole new back 4.

[JayC 171]

So athleticism in your book is speed only huh?

What about RvP's body strength? Leg strength? Body balance? Suppleness? Leaping ability? etc.

Not only speed no, but in terms of Hazard vs Mata, I would think that is the major difference between the two - Hazards superior pace. So I made some examples of how pace isn't a necessity to a footballer.

[Thor 2,689]

Not only speed no, but in terms of Hazard vs Mata, I would think that is the major difference between the two - Hazards superior pace. So I made some examples of how pace isn't a necessity to a footballer.

Hazard is a better player. I think you just need to accept that. Mata is a great player, but with glaring holes in his game, unlike Hazard.

Hes pushed off the ball easily, unlike Hazard.

Hes slow for a player his size, unlike Hazard.

Has an average first touch, unlike Hazard.

Not to mention Hazard draws more attention and breaks defenses down far better than Mata ever has, even in his first season.

The only trait Mata has over Hazard is his passing ability.

What Hazard has done this season is better than anything Mata has done for us.

[JayC 171]

Hazard is a better player. I think you just need to accept that. Mata is a great player, but with glaring holes in his game, unlike Hazard.

Hes pushed off the ball easily, unlike Hazard.

Hes slow for a player his size, unlike Hazard.

Has an average first touch, unlike Hazard.

Not to mention Hazard draws more attention and breaks defenses down far better than Mata ever has, even in his first season.

The only trait Mata has over Hazard is his passing ability.

What Hazard has done this season is better than anything Mata has done for us.

It's truly amazing how much a players value/ability/skill goes down hill, when they aren't your player anymore. ;p

[Thor 2,689]

It's truly amazing how much a players value/ability/skill goes down hill, when they aren't your player anymore. ;p

You can find my posts on Mata in here throughout mid season, and even just as recently as this season. I've always maintained what I said above. He simply isn't as good as Hazard.

I even prefer Willian and Oscar over Mata, although, if anyone were to go, I would have kept Mata and got rid of Schurlle.

[mediator 2,026]

Has an average first touch

I don't agree with that, he has a great first touch and nice ball control

The only problem with him, is the work rate to recover the ball while pressing (according to José standards).

He was drop because Oscar is better defender than him, but for the attacking part, there is no comparaison between them, Mata > Oscar any day (he shouldn't be compare to Hazard, Mata is a #10)

May be we should try a line up with 10 CB next time

[JayC 171]

You can find my posts on Mata in here throughout mid season, and even just as recently as this season. I've always maintained what I said above. He simply isn't as good as Hazard.

I even prefer Willian and Oscar over Mata, although, if anyone were to go, I would have kept Mata and got rid of Schurlle.

Fair play to you then, if it's your genuine opinion.

[1chelsea 864]

Seem fan when for hike to clear their head off this mata transfer completion. All thread look quiet

[The only place to be 11,313]

Really? There is more to it than a system change. Much more, in my opinion. You don't simply throw away a player of Mata's quality. You find a space for them. The last game I saw Mata play for Chelsea he was dragged off after doing nothing wrong for the entire game. It's all very strange.

The Southampton game? Unfortunately that game pretty much summed up Mata's place in our system. He did nothing wrong but we just weren't firing like we have been in other games. The introduction of Willian and Oscar brought pace and directness to the game both in attack and defence. It's not an isolated incident either.

Mata simply doesn't fit in our team anymore and making space for him completely changes the way the team plays. Benitez got away with playing him because he built the entire system around him and accepted that he will bring certain weaknesses to the team. That's fine when he's playing well but on off-days (and he did have them) then the whole team looks poor.

You've got yourself a great player but he has to be used in a very specific way. Fortunately you've got a tactical genius in charge

[Jase 43,479]

If we take the bones out of all this we are left with one common denominator and that is why the fook are we selling to Scum U? Cundy said last night on talksport that he had genuine info back in the summer that Jose didn't fancy Mata, so my question is why did we not sell him to PSG when they offered us 40m back then?

I'm not one to believe Guillem Balague considering of his Spanish bias and dislike of Mourinho etc but he might just have a point here in relation to what Cundy said..

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/teams/manchester-united/10593633/Chelsea-manager-Jose-Mourinho-did-not-speak-to-Juan-Mata-he-had-no-choice-but-to-leave.html

[Superblue 6,372]

In terms of overall ability they can be compared - Mata currently has more; out-performing Hazard every season he's had equal opportunity in. He is more naturally gifted in my opinion too. I see where you are coming from to a point though. Hazard can get better, but so can Mata.

See one of my posts a few pages back. In a way I can agree in that I think Mata is a better playmaker than Hazard, but Hazard is a much better fit in the Premier League with his pace, running power and dynamism. I'm not sure it's a coincidence that we are much better this season and challenging at the top without the team built to play to Mata's strengths. I also believe that Hazard had a better first season than Mata's first stats wise.

If United had the choice to buy either Hazard or Mata for £37m they would buy Hazard every single time because he is the better fit both for their side and the Premier League. Mata is a superb player but the team must be built around him to play to his strengths and the team must be solid behind him (which at the moment you're not). When all fit you're best three players are RVP, Rooney and Mata and to accommodate all of them in the starting line up someone will be played out of position or Moyes will have to change formation meaning playing more of a poor crop of midfielders you have at the club.

Also take into account that Mata even when he's had opportunities this season (and Jose had given him them) has been largely poor and not contributed much. I'm not saying he's suddenly a bad player but you are buying him for top money at a time when his stock is probably at it's lowest. I think over time he will do very well for United if the team plays to his strengths but that won't necessarily mean the team will be successful.

[CHOULO19 24,332]

Mata deserves better anyway. He made the right choice. We won't bench him.

By the way, you just sold us your best player. Thanks. I'd try and care about your feelings on this, but after reading the thread and comments made about my club I don't seem to be able to give a damn.

By the way, you just broke your transfer record for a player who couldn't make our starting XI

[didierforever 7,349]

Lol You? My favourite player is JT. Imagine how I felt when I found out

he mihht not be my favourite-est player but he ranks somehwere right at the top. He truly is our CLL and to find this out is just heart wrenching to say the least.