I think the problem was that he was recalled to early from his loan. I mean, right after he said yes, i come back (as you asked me to come back), we signed willian and schuurle. One more season abroad, we would have someone else in our squad ready to fight for his place without the pressure of the world cup. He was told he had a future with us, and right after, we signed 2 more wingers. So i think the board saw something in him that José didn't. End of Story